 In Los Angeles on Monday 13 September 1937, Federal Judge Vincent L.  Leibell dismissed the song copyright infringement suit bought by  George A. Cogniate and United Music Corp. against Universal  Pictures. Gem Picture Productions, LowesInc., Consolidated  Amuesments Enterprises, Universal Film Exchanges, Big U Film  Exchange and the Woodside Operating Corp. Cogniate claimed that  three French songs were used as background music in the Universal  1933