 After another food fight at school, Brooke and Carmen decide they are so over high school and high school boys. During breakfast Nicole asks her mother to take a look at her college essay on what it is like to be adopted, revealing to her mother that she has found her birth mother wanting the two to meet. Nicole s mother refuses to meet or hear her name ever again. Sam is feeling guilty that she has hurt Harrison, George try to sway her fears about him not wanting to talk to her again, giving her a kiss that Harrison sees, and Sam notices Harrison walking by. During a college fair at Kennedy High, Brooke is invited to a frat party by a sorority sister she meets. Brooke talks Carmen, Lilly and Sam into going along with her. When Josh and George come along smuggling cookie doe in to throw the girls all decide to go. Nicole and her mother meet with Ms. Glass about her options when Nicole s birth mother arrives having invited her to the parent teacher conference. Shaggy is given the cold shoulder by Nicole s mother, Ms. Glass steps in advising that they deal with the situation suggesting a dinner. Josh and George plan to crash the frat party inviting Harrison along. The night of the party Brooke goes over with the girls her plan which starts with circular reasoning, cover the wagon, operation divide an conquer. Plans go awry when Lilly and Sam get caught and are forced to spend the night with Sam and Brooke s parents for a night of baking cookies and board games. Meanwhile at the Julian house the dinner doesn t go as well as Nicole would have liked, with much resistance from her adopted mother. Nicole and her mother go out in the hall to talk when her mother realizes one of her pre-columbian artifacts is missing accusing Shaggy of stealing it. Brooke and Carmen decide to go to the party without Sam and Lily who are trapped in game night with Mike and Jane which they are not enjoying. Ms. Glass spots the artifact that Judy accused Shaggy of stealing angering Nicole who storms out of the house. Brooke and Carmen are quickly split up when a college guy gives Carmen a tour and Brooke experience what college girls are really like. Josh, Harrison and George have the wrong idea about College party life, obviously having watched to many movies, being tossed out with the trash literally. Brooke bumps into a college guy by the name of Jamie Roth that suits her fancy. Carmen finds out first hand just what college boys are really like when one tries to go too far with her scaring her. She hides in the closet trying to contact Brooke who has been thrown out after a sorority sister sees her talking to Jamie her ex-boyfriend. Josh, George and Harrison arrive in time to help a frantic Carmen rescuing her. Nicole discovers that the woman pretending to be her biological mother just may not really be who she clams when she catches her trying to bribe her adopted mother. Nicole finally has the moment she s always yearned for with her adopted mother who finally tells her that she loves her and would have given anything not to lose her. Brooke and Carmen realize that high school and their stinky guys aren t so bad after all, and they have it better then they thought, resulting in a jello food fight which this time the girls start.