 Josh (Rob Alicea) always looked up to his older and devious brother, Gino (Chris Keogh), when they were children growing up in Italy, just before they moved to New York. Now in America, they have taken very opposite paths, quite different than expected, with the naughty kid Gino even becoming a priest. When Josh s posh penthouse is robbed, the trail leads Detective Garza (Connie James) to Father Gino and it sends Josh on an unexpected journey toward a brother he only thinks he knows. Could Gino really have done this? A priest? Now things are very different, or are they?