 After losing Craig, Manny decides to throw Liberty a birthday party at Emma s house while her parents are away. What was supposed to be a small birthday party ends up being a huge bash with Lakehurst guys as well. Liberty admits to JT that she still loves him, but he doesn t tell her he feels the same. JT then has a conversation with Toby including Mia and Liberty. Sean and Emma try to make it "the night" but noisy party-goers pose a threat to them. Later, something horrible happens making the night a tragic one they will never forget.