 Told in a non-linear order, this episode is the story of one night that changed everything between Nathan and Lucas and Haley and Peyton. At an away game, Lucas and Nathan both get kicked out for fighting, each other. Brook twists her ankle and offers Haley a ride home from the game. Lucas and Nathan are kicked off the bus and forced to walk home when they are kidnapped by members of the opposing team, the Pirates. The two groups must get over their differences to get home.