 Valerie s civil lawsuit against Noah begins with her taking the witness stand testifying about that night. But Noah s attorney viciously cross-examines her by making use of Valerie s sordid past to discredit her. Next to testify is the doctor who examined Valerie who confirms she was indeed drugged and had sex with Noah. But Noah s attorney tries to counter it by implying that Valerie deliberately drugged herself. Then Brandon, Kelly, and Steve individually take the witness stand and testify against Valerie, despite her attorney who tries to put a reasonable doubt on them. But the final nail is when Noah s defense receives a mortal blow when the real culprit, Josh, unexpectedly takes the witness stand and testifies against Noah with details about "his" version of what happened the Valentine s Day night with Valerie at the After Dark. Meanwhile, Donna s addiction to pain pills spins out of control when she begins stealing pills from her father s medicine cabinet at his clinic while she also combats work pressure by plagiarizing another co-worker s ideas for her newest designs. Also, a record company executive wants to sign on David, but not Jasper.