 In 1997 Vincent Doan is convicted of kidnapping and murdering his 22-year old girlfriend, Carrie Culberson, even though her body has never been found. Doan claims the former cheerleader vanished along with her red Honda in late August 1996. He believes he was wrongly convicted and that Carrie is still alive. But authorities say Doan ran with a tough crowd and had a record of alleged abuse. Police and prosecutors are confident the right man is behind bars and that Carrie is dead. Doan s father, half-brother, and even the police chief were also accused of helping to cover-up the crime. The small village of Blanchester, Ohio, outside of Cincinnati, remains divided as both families continue their endless search for the truth and for Carrie Culberson.