 After Lucas crowns another good game with the winning point, Nathan switches to plan B, inviting him to a party at his dad s luxurious beach house where he cleverly humiliates him with a truth game and a video of Lucas ma calling Dan her dream husband. After Lucas walks out livid, Haley is stranded, accepts a ride back from Nathan in Peyton s car and accepts to keep tutoring him since failing grades would kill all his and Dan s dreams. On his way back Nathan crashes into Lucas in the car of one of Keith s clients; Nathan thinks he can bluff his way out making Tim his false witness, but there are nasty consequences for both brothers, their girls friends and their parents.