 FAIR: In one episode, Brooke calls Peyton by her full name "Peyton  Elizabeth Sawyer" (her mother even says that her middle name is  Elizabeth). However, when Peyton goes to get Haley, when Haley is  with Chris, Peyton tells Haley how, lately shes been angry, and  Peyton says that Brooke calls her "Peyton Marie Sawyer 