 FAKE: When Ashley comes to Atlanta for Christmas during the war, he  and Melanie go upstairs to bed and call over the banister of the  staircase landing to Scarlett. They proceed on to their room and we  see the light from their room reflected on the wall at the staircase  landing. We see the light disappear as their bedroom door closes,  leaving Scarlett watching in misery as Ashley goes to bed with  Melanie. However, when we see Prissy and Scarlett packing to leave  Atlanta because Sherman is coming (while Melanie is in labor) it  appears that there is no bedroom in a position that could leave a  light on the landing wall as seen during the Christmas Visit scene.